Share Your Comments

Name*
Email*
ARN No/Firm Name*
City*
Comments*
Verification Code*
nNpMAS
Type the characters in the picture.
We trust that you will avoid using harsh language and will refrain from making unsubstantiated allegations against individuals and firms. Your constructive feedback and opinions are very valuable to all of us in the industry.

Liked this article?
Rate it on WF Like-o-meter!

Name*
Email*
(Name and Email ID will not be displayed once you click Submit)
Your rating : Click the appropriate pointer from the 5 below
(Low signifies didn't like and High signifies liked a lot)
WF Like-o-Meter

Check out the WF Like-o-meter score for
this article

0
Comments Posted
Name : Bhadresh PatelCity : Bharuch
ARN NO : 58011Date : 24 Sep 2015
Comments :
Sir, Please share your valuable article at my Mail ID bhadresh1977@gmail.com
Name : Sumit Nahata City : Surat
ARN NO : 27531 Date : 20 Sep 2015
Comments :
Sir, send me a copy of this on email.
Name : Stanislaus DsouzaCity : Shirva, Udupi District
ARN NO : 40706Date : 24 Oct 2014
Comments :
Thank you very much Hari sir. I will be very grateful to you, if you please send a copy of this comparison to my mail. Thank you once again. My mail id is: stanislausdsouza@yahoo.com
Name : AravindCity : Nellore
ARN NO : 95976Date : 21 Oct 2014
Comments :
Excellent presentation sir. Please mail either excel or word format to my mail id sir. Thanking you. aravind2001@gmail.com Rgds Aravind
Name : SUMIT NAHATACity : SURAT
ARN NO : 27531Date : 07 Aug 2014
Comments :
KAMATH SIR, THE COMPARISON IS VERY HELPFUL. WILL BE GRATEFUL IF YOU CAN SEND US THE EXCEL AT gotoinvest@gmail.com. THANK YOU
Name : Kiran Rao City : Bangalore
ARN NO : 78548Date : 05 Aug 2014
Comments :
Sira I am an IFA from Bangalore i read u r article it is good comparison. sir if you have the same comparison in MS word or excel u can send it to my email . email id is reachkiran05@gmail.com it will help me a lot Sir.
Name : jugal k marwahaCity : jalandhar
ARN NO : 2268Date : 20 Jul 2014
Comments :
HARI KAMAT JI YOUR INFORMATION ARE TOO VALUABLE, I BELIEVE THIS WILL HELP TO INCREASE ELSS.
Name : Smita GaunekarCity : Margao
ARN NO : GoaDate : 20 Jul 2014
Comments :
I sincerely regret not listening to you when you advised me the same in 2004. However its better late than never. Have started the same in 2010 with excellent results. Thank You for letting me know about such products which actually create wealth.
Name : ganesh babu City : madurai
ARN NO : 28486Date : 19 Jul 2014
Comments :
Good idea and I will take this live example and do have more ppf clients to elss schemes
Name : EPURU RAMACHANDRAMCity : HYDERABAD
ARN NO : 45122Date : 17 Jul 2014
Comments :
YES IT WILL HELP TO MOBILISE MORE SAVING IN ELSS.
Name : N C JAISWALCity : GORAKHPUR UP
ARN NO : ARN-2899Date : 17 Jul 2014
Comments :
It is a opportunity for M F advisior we can sale of ELSS Rs- 50000/- extra ammont our all exiting investors
Name : Surendra Kumar SinghCity : Kolkata
ARN NO : 77358Date : 17 Jul 2014
Comments :
Dear Mr. Kamat, Your article is an eye opener for every investor who will read this artilcle because most of the investor want to invest their money in PPF instead of ELSS. They have exhausted their 80C limit of 1 lakh by investing only in PPF. Henceforth They will definitely allocate money to ELSS. The increase in the limit by Rs.50,000 in the present financial year has given them the opportunity to invest as per your suggestion.
Name : Bhunje DhananjayCity : Baramati
ARN NO : 30886Date : 16 Jul 2014
Comments :
This is great thing for IFA in this crucial period.this is the motivation for geeting more Income.
Name : KL KalyanakrishnanCity : Thane
ARN NO : 14046Date : 16 Jul 2014
Comments :
Excellent effort by Mr Hari Kamat. Hats off to him as well as to WealthForum. Indeed it is an eye opener to the IFAs as well as to the prospective clients. Generaly the tendancy is to withdraw from the ELSS after the lock-in period of three years or at an appropriate opportunity. If it is kept for 15 years, as is shown by Mr Kamat, it can do wonders.
Name : vinod bhutadaCity : nashik
ARN NO : 43455Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
very nice working,hope this will help to all of us & will create wealth for people.
Name : SundarCity : Chennai
ARN NO : 90787Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thanks You sir... Though we all know that Elss will out beat PPF, you have precisely worked and showed everyone that by what quantum it can outperform. Good data.
Name : AshwiniCity : Amravati
ARN NO : AmravatiDate : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Dear Mr. Kamat, Your article is an eye opener for investor like me because I have been exhausting my 80C limit of 1 lakh by investing only in PPF. Henceforth I will definitely allocate money to ELSS. The increase in the limit by Rs.50,000 in the present financial year has given me the opportunity to invest as per your suggestion.
Name : MalikCity : Panjim
ARN NO : PanjimDate : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very usefull and live calculation. Hope all MF distributors utilise the same.
Name : U D KhandolCity : Bhuj
ARN NO : 66926Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very True and useful information. Keep sharing.
Name : Amol ChitaleCity : Solapur
ARN NO : 30587Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Data and Statistics for Mutual fund Investments is Compelling. Unfortunately the average income tax payer (Especially Salaried Class) is refusing to be convinced. It is not just PPF ,the same argument holds true for other comparisons too. In fact it even holds true against Real Estate. Just compare any piece of real estate with returns generated by Reliance Growth over 19 years ! Prospects simply ignore or disregard that " Time Creates Value ".
Name : Sonia MehtaCity : Panjim
ARN NO : GoaDate : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Excellent data and a real eye opener. This data will really help all of us.
Name : ASHOK kAKKADCity : RAJKOT
ARN NO : 86902Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very good information Hariji. Thanks a Lot. for HUF we can take all 1.5 lacs.
Name : ALAMURI NAGARAJUCity : VIJAYAWADA
ARN NO : ARN-4878Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
SIR, GOOD AND GREAT WORK. ITS A TOOL FOR ADVISORS
Name : S.RAVISANKARCity : Ariyalur,Trichy,Tamil Nadu
ARN NO : ARN-38648Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Good data. Thanks,sir
Name : Mira shuklaCity : Bangalore
ARN NO : ARN-40650Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Dear Hari Sir, Very informative and practical example. Very good chart prepared by you . Thank you so much for sharing this information.
Name : SOUMITRA ROYCity : kalyani
ARN NO : ARN-57810Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
VERY INFORMATIVE ARTICLE.THE COMPARISON CHART IS EXCELLENT. THANK YOU SIR.
Name : Haseen AnsariCity : Varanasi
ARN NO : ARN-32305Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
It is very useful to attract new investor.
Name : SANDEEP J SHUKLACity : MUMBAI
ARN NO : ARN-0418Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
If you will take the average period of holding for any investor, it would be more than 15 years. Average balance of any PPF A/C holder would be more than 15 lacs. If you will verify that why investor could accumulate such amount. There were five reasons. (1)Investor were focus for investing 15 years. (2) Most of the investor used to invest Rs.100000 or maximum amount every year regularly. (4) Most of the investor has never withdrawn any amount form the account. PPF was the last priority for withdrawal (5) PPF Int was taxfree. If any investor applies same principal for any diversified equity fund for next 15 -20-25 years. He can create wealth over the period.
Name : V.M.KudtarkarCity : Vasco da Gama, Goa
ARN NO : ARN-13178Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very useful input. ... Thanks Hari Sir.
Name : DB DESAICity : KUDAL
ARN NO : 0234Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Excellent calculations and comparision as an eye opener. Convincing the client with this data will be easier and more than that customer can understand it better than other ways of talking about the returns like absolute, CAGR etc. More calculated arguments and articles expected from Mr. Hari Kamat.
Name : PAWAN AGRAWALCity : NEW DELHI
ARN NO : 25741Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
VERY WELL PUT HARIJI.
Name : BIDYUT BANERJEECity : BANKURA
ARN NO : 7291Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
THANK YOU SIR.
Name : Dinesh BhanushaliCity : Daman
ARN NO : 63185Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Lots of thanks kamat sir, this is truly an eye opening for IFAs
Name : PandurangCity : Buldana
ARN NO : 51244Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very useful input. ... Thanks sir
Name : Navin KumarCity : Patna
ARN NO : 83441Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Great idea sir....
Name : sandeep kimtiCity : Mandsaur
ARN NO : ARN-62633Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thank u sir.
Name : M GanesanCity : Pethaniapuram,Madurai
ARN NO : 8097Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thanks.A very useful data/eye opener to all IFAs to do more SIPs
Name : shiva prasad konduruCity : WARANGAL
ARN NO : 47847Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
good update thanks
Name : nikhil girmeCity : Pune
ARN NO : 39636Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
this is a great help and useful input ...thanks a lot sir
Name : RAJIV KUMARCity : NEW DELHI
ARN NO : 37312Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thanks for your update.Will use it to impress upon clients/ investors.
Submit Your Comments
Name
ARN No/Co Name
Comments
Verification Code
* Email *
* City *
*
*
nNpMAS
Type the characters in the picture.
We trust that you will avoid using harsh language and will refrain from making unsubstantiated allegations against individuals and firms. Your constructive feedback and opinions are very valuable to all of us in the industry.
 
Comments Posted
Name : Bhadresh PatelCity : Bharuch
ARN NO : 58011Date : 24 Sep 2015
Comments :
Sir, Please share your valuable article at my Mail ID bhadresh1977@gmail.com
Name : Sumit Nahata City : Surat
ARN NO : 27531 Date : 20 Sep 2015
Comments :
Sir, send me a copy of this on email.
Name : Stanislaus DsouzaCity : Shirva, Udupi District
ARN NO : 40706Date : 24 Oct 2014
Comments :
Thank you very much Hari sir. I will be very grateful to you, if you please send a copy of this comparison to my mail. Thank you once again. My mail id is: stanislausdsouza@yahoo.com
Name : AravindCity : Nellore
ARN NO : 95976Date : 21 Oct 2014
Comments :
Excellent presentation sir. Please mail either excel or word format to my mail id sir. Thanking you. aravind2001@gmail.com Rgds Aravind
Name : SUMIT NAHATACity : SURAT
ARN NO : 27531Date : 07 Aug 2014
Comments :
KAMATH SIR, THE COMPARISON IS VERY HELPFUL. WILL BE GRATEFUL IF YOU CAN SEND US THE EXCEL AT gotoinvest@gmail.com. THANK YOU
Name : Kiran Rao City : Bangalore
ARN NO : 78548Date : 05 Aug 2014
Comments :
Sira I am an IFA from Bangalore i read u r article it is good comparison. sir if you have the same comparison in MS word or excel u can send it to my email . email id is reachkiran05@gmail.com it will help me a lot Sir.
Name : jugal k marwahaCity : jalandhar
ARN NO : 2268Date : 20 Jul 2014
Comments :
HARI KAMAT JI YOUR INFORMATION ARE TOO VALUABLE, I BELIEVE THIS WILL HELP TO INCREASE ELSS.
Name : Smita GaunekarCity : Margao
ARN NO : GoaDate : 20 Jul 2014
Comments :
I sincerely regret not listening to you when you advised me the same in 2004. However its better late than never. Have started the same in 2010 with excellent results. Thank You for letting me know about such products which actually create wealth.
Name : ganesh babu City : madurai
ARN NO : 28486Date : 19 Jul 2014
Comments :
Good idea and I will take this live example and do have more ppf clients to elss schemes
Name : EPURU RAMACHANDRAMCity : HYDERABAD
ARN NO : 45122Date : 17 Jul 2014
Comments :
YES IT WILL HELP TO MOBILISE MORE SAVING IN ELSS.
Name : N C JAISWALCity : GORAKHPUR UP
ARN NO : ARN-2899Date : 17 Jul 2014
Comments :
It is a opportunity for M F advisior we can sale of ELSS Rs- 50000/- extra ammont our all exiting investors
Name : Surendra Kumar SinghCity : Kolkata
ARN NO : 77358Date : 17 Jul 2014
Comments :
Dear Mr. Kamat, Your article is an eye opener for every investor who will read this artilcle because most of the investor want to invest their money in PPF instead of ELSS. They have exhausted their 80C limit of 1 lakh by investing only in PPF. Henceforth They will definitely allocate money to ELSS. The increase in the limit by Rs.50,000 in the present financial year has given them the opportunity to invest as per your suggestion.
Name : Bhunje DhananjayCity : Baramati
ARN NO : 30886Date : 16 Jul 2014
Comments :
This is great thing for IFA in this crucial period.this is the motivation for geeting more Income.
Name : KL KalyanakrishnanCity : Thane
ARN NO : 14046Date : 16 Jul 2014
Comments :
Excellent effort by Mr Hari Kamat. Hats off to him as well as to WealthForum. Indeed it is an eye opener to the IFAs as well as to the prospective clients. Generaly the tendancy is to withdraw from the ELSS after the lock-in period of three years or at an appropriate opportunity. If it is kept for 15 years, as is shown by Mr Kamat, it can do wonders.
Name : vinod bhutadaCity : nashik
ARN NO : 43455Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
very nice working,hope this will help to all of us & will create wealth for people.
Name : SundarCity : Chennai
ARN NO : 90787Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thanks You sir... Though we all know that Elss will out beat PPF, you have precisely worked and showed everyone that by what quantum it can outperform. Good data.
Name : AshwiniCity : Amravati
ARN NO : AmravatiDate : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Dear Mr. Kamat, Your article is an eye opener for investor like me because I have been exhausting my 80C limit of 1 lakh by investing only in PPF. Henceforth I will definitely allocate money to ELSS. The increase in the limit by Rs.50,000 in the present financial year has given me the opportunity to invest as per your suggestion.
Name : MalikCity : Panjim
ARN NO : PanjimDate : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very usefull and live calculation. Hope all MF distributors utilise the same.
Name : U D KhandolCity : Bhuj
ARN NO : 66926Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very True and useful information. Keep sharing.
Name : Amol ChitaleCity : Solapur
ARN NO : 30587Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Data and Statistics for Mutual fund Investments is Compelling. Unfortunately the average income tax payer (Especially Salaried Class) is refusing to be convinced. It is not just PPF ,the same argument holds true for other comparisons too. In fact it even holds true against Real Estate. Just compare any piece of real estate with returns generated by Reliance Growth over 19 years ! Prospects simply ignore or disregard that " Time Creates Value ".
Name : Sonia MehtaCity : Panjim
ARN NO : GoaDate : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Excellent data and a real eye opener. This data will really help all of us.
Name : ASHOK kAKKADCity : RAJKOT
ARN NO : 86902Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very good information Hariji. Thanks a Lot. for HUF we can take all 1.5 lacs.
Name : ALAMURI NAGARAJUCity : VIJAYAWADA
ARN NO : ARN-4878Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
SIR, GOOD AND GREAT WORK. ITS A TOOL FOR ADVISORS
Name : S.RAVISANKARCity : Ariyalur,Trichy,Tamil Nadu
ARN NO : ARN-38648Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Good data. Thanks,sir
Name : Mira shuklaCity : Bangalore
ARN NO : ARN-40650Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Dear Hari Sir, Very informative and practical example. Very good chart prepared by you . Thank you so much for sharing this information.
Name : SOUMITRA ROYCity : kalyani
ARN NO : ARN-57810Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
VERY INFORMATIVE ARTICLE.THE COMPARISON CHART IS EXCELLENT. THANK YOU SIR.
Name : Haseen AnsariCity : Varanasi
ARN NO : ARN-32305Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
It is very useful to attract new investor.
Name : SANDEEP J SHUKLACity : MUMBAI
ARN NO : ARN-0418Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
If you will take the average period of holding for any investor, it would be more than 15 years. Average balance of any PPF A/C holder would be more than 15 lacs. If you will verify that why investor could accumulate such amount. There were five reasons. (1)Investor were focus for investing 15 years. (2) Most of the investor used to invest Rs.100000 or maximum amount every year regularly. (4) Most of the investor has never withdrawn any amount form the account. PPF was the last priority for withdrawal (5) PPF Int was taxfree. If any investor applies same principal for any diversified equity fund for next 15 -20-25 years. He can create wealth over the period.
Name : V.M.KudtarkarCity : Vasco da Gama, Goa
ARN NO : ARN-13178Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very useful input. ... Thanks Hari Sir.
Name : DB DESAICity : KUDAL
ARN NO : 0234Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Excellent calculations and comparision as an eye opener. Convincing the client with this data will be easier and more than that customer can understand it better than other ways of talking about the returns like absolute, CAGR etc. More calculated arguments and articles expected from Mr. Hari Kamat.
Name : PAWAN AGRAWALCity : NEW DELHI
ARN NO : 25741Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
VERY WELL PUT HARIJI.
Name : BIDYUT BANERJEECity : BANKURA
ARN NO : 7291Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
THANK YOU SIR.
Name : Dinesh BhanushaliCity : Daman
ARN NO : 63185Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Lots of thanks kamat sir, this is truly an eye opening for IFAs
Name : PandurangCity : Buldana
ARN NO : 51244Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Very useful input. ... Thanks sir
Name : Navin KumarCity : Patna
ARN NO : 83441Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Great idea sir....
Name : sandeep kimtiCity : Mandsaur
ARN NO : ARN-62633Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thank u sir.
Name : M GanesanCity : Pethaniapuram,Madurai
ARN NO : 8097Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thanks.A very useful data/eye opener to all IFAs to do more SIPs
Name : shiva prasad konduruCity : WARANGAL
ARN NO : 47847Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
good update thanks
Name : nikhil girmeCity : Pune
ARN NO : 39636Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
this is a great help and useful input ...thanks a lot sir
Name : RAJIV KUMARCity : NEW DELHI
ARN NO : 37312Date : 15 Jul 2014
Comments :
Thanks for your update.Will use it to impress upon clients/ investors.